Valuation Watch: Housing Order Bets on AVMs, Cap Rates Stay Stuck

Trump’s new housing order leans hard on AVMs — and leaves the fairness questions open

The October 22 executive order, “Decreasing Housing Costs for the American People,” writes automated valuation into federal policy: it directs FHFA to pilot a program that cancels mortgage insurance premiums once a borrower’s equity, “as determined through an automated valuation model or other means approved by the Director,” crosses a set threshold, has the GSEs lean on AVMs and other data to assess current market value across their loan books, and lines up appraisal waivers for cash-out refinances “where the Enterprise’s existing data support doing so.” It’s a meaningful vote of confidence for alternative-valuation providers, but the order is notably silent on guardrails: no accuracy threshold, no bias-testing requirement, no borrower dispute process — so cost reduction and valuation integrity will both be worth watching as FHFA fills in the pilot’s details.

Cap rates are stuck, not falling — and that has refinancing implications

Cap rates haven’t softened the way lenders hoped in 2026 — Newmark calls them “generally stable,” with all-asset rates around 6.3–6.4%, about 60 bps above model-implied levels and up from 5.2% in late 2021. Multifamily is flattest, stuck at 5.7% for seven straight quarters (a 25-year record); office stays bifurcated between strong and challenged assets, industrial is “moving toward balance,” and retail benefits from tight supply.

The practical read-through for lenders: wide bid-ask spreads mean sellers are still anchoring to older valuations while buyers underwrite conservatively, so appraised values can lag where deals actually clear, a real risk for 2021–22 vintage loans facing refinance in the next cycle. If you’re reassessing collateral values ahead of 2026–27 maturities, Eval’s evaluation and validation products are built for exactly this kind of check-in — request pricing or sample work products here to see how they fit your portfolio review.

A Smarter Way to Value

Request sample reports, fee schedules and a due diligence package.